I always enjoy guessing on ID
but I do it mostly by process of elimination. If you can get them to look at the invoice and see if they can determine which body of water it came from (explain that temperature is important and nudge them a little to put out an effort if need be) we can get closest.
Looking at the prominant eyes and quick taper on the arms, I am thinking a nocturnal dwarf species. Considering the two dwarf species in the Caribbean, I think the arms are too long for O.
mercatoris but not for O.
joubini. If it shows cripsis (bumps on the mantle when it is in camo mode typically on LR) then
joubini can be eliminated. The coloring in the top two photos look too red for joubini (they tend toward the yellow browns from the two I have seen), however, the last photo does look joubinish. The other dwarf that we don't see often,
digueti (Pacific Coast) but
Roy's photo makes me think the arms are shorter like the merc (I don't think I could tell a merc from a digueti but other reading suggest they have longer arms than the merc).
Officially, my guess is O.
digueti but keep in mind my species exposure is very limited and I have not seen this species in anything but photos.