Editorial: The '05 Living Architeuthis Photos


Webmaster thoughts on the first photos of living giant squid, in 2005.

Note:
Tony welcomes discussion on this article in this thread on our forums.

65687


By Tony Morelli

Last updated: 10/1/05

Introduction

I've been maintaining TONMO.com as a cephalopod interest site since 2000. Since then, there have been two pivotal news events which have caused traffic to my site to increase exponentially (literally).

The first was in April of 2003 when Dr. Steve O'Shea and Kat Bolstad (who are also TONMO.com staff members in their "spare time") announced that their research had yielded realization that Mesonychoteuthis is a uniquely giant squid, and in fact is larger (and has more fearsome features, such as razor-sharp hooks) than the Giant Squid, Architeuthis. In response (and in conjunction with Auckland University of Technology's own PR efforts), news outlets from around the world picked up the story of the newly discovered "Colossal Squid", replete with depictions of "Messie" as a unit of measurement, pitted against such things as a scuba diver and a double-decker bus. As a result, we found Web surfers from around the globe flocking to TONMO.com to interact with Dr. O'Shea and Kat to learn a bit more about these mysterious, sensationalized creatures.

The second event occurred earlier this week when a team of Japanese scientists took 556 digital photos of a living Architeuthis and shared them with the press (albeit one year later), resulting in great fanfare comparable to the Colossal Squid discovery. What has so far not been digested by the press (and is not likely to, as that news cycle has already long passed) is the slightly uglier underside of the way that the living Architeuthis was observed.

No doubt the few pictures which have been released are incredible and represent an historic step forward in understanding these animals. The significance of this event should not be compromised, and for the most part, based solely on the reach of the press coverage, it hasn't. However, when considering that the Architeuthis was lured with bait, then got itself stuck on a hooked lure, and struggled for four hours (as the pictures were taken) to the point of ripping off one of its two tentacles to gain freedom, it becomes apparent that there are deeper aspects of this story worth exploring as well.

Ethics

The more complicated aspect of this story is the seemingly ubiquitous issue of ethics in wild animal observation. The means to gain the photographs as described above should force us all to ask ourselves whether there isn't a better way to achieve our goal. The accomplishment itself should be celebrated, but the stress imposed on the rare and majestic Architeuthis should be criticized, if only to ensure we can better empathize and respect this species as a fellow creature of Earth and not a fearsome monster of the deep with whom we're embattled.

It would seem a cost-effective approach was taken to secure the images -- a bag of shrimp bait, a submerged digital camera taking 150 KB jpeg images every thirty seconds, and, basically, a giant hook. The quality and value of the photos yet to be released is difficult to predict, but the volume should give us confidence that we'll be reaping much more from this event than we have thus far. Regardless, a debate continues as to the ethics of capturing this data at the expense of the creature. Should the project have been halted before launch (indeed, in the design phase) due to consideration for the welfare of the giant squid? Clearly the impaling hook was the key ingredient in order to halt the squid and take photos, otherwise the project may not have been cost-justified (for example, with photos being taken every 30 seconds, without a hook, the team would risk having its shrimp be eaten without ever capturing Architeuthis on film).

This was a plan with a basic form: the clear goal was to capture images of a living Architeuthis via a process optimized for success, both tactically and financially.

Where to from here?

The second and more obvious question is, where do we go next? The painfully elusive task of photographing Architeuthis has finally been completed with success, without question. The next step for Architeuthis, per Dr. O'Shea, is to capture its living larvae and raise it in captivity. This is undoubtedly a much more logistically difficult task, and is not likely to be any more immune to the debate over ethics in animal study. Still, the fruits of this effort are likely to contain a wealth of new learning; the recorded data should easily surpass this latest event in terms of both captured image and written observation, albeit with younger, smaller specimens (which will grow... and it is unknown what Dr. O'Shea has in mind when that happens!).

While the new photographs are indeed what scientists have been striving to obtain for a decade (and longer), they are not a replacement for the equally epic quest for video footage of Architeuthis in a natural setting. We should expect resources will continue to be expended for expeditions which clandestinely observe and videotape grown specimens under natural conditions.

We'd also be remiss not to acknowledge that the Colossal Squid itself, Mesonychoteuthis, has not yet been observed alive. In modern terms, "Old and Busted: Architeuthis; The New Hotness: Mesonychoteuthis".

Summary

In the end, the living Architeuthis project was a complete success and the world has gained (and still stands to gain) invaluable knowledge from the images themselves. The new discovery and the means by which it was made will help propel our understanding of large squid species, so long as we don't neglect what we stood to learn from the event itself, both intended and consequential.
Original publish date
Dec 30, 2005
About the Author
tonmo
Tony converted TONMO.com into an octopus and cephalopod interest site in May 2000. (Find out more about how TONMO started by reading this blog entry.) He began his career in the online services industry in 1992, working for companies such as Prodigy, iVillage.com, Reuters and Comcast. Tony and his wife Tania are the owners of Deep Intuition, LLC, which is an entity they created to support their entrepreneurial hobbies and pursuits. He graduated from St. Bonaventure University with a B.A. in Mass Communication and lives in Pennsylvania.

More in Other Cephalopod Articles

DHF8
8 min read
Views
552
Comments
2
For anyone interested the following is a transcript of my half of an introductory talk, delivered today at the 'Multispecies Heritage Conference' (hosted by Edge Hill Univeristy in the UK). [raw text, not corrected], that serves to introduce our cephalopod-media project to a wider audience...
Contributing Authors
William Brown
Original publish date
Nov 27, 2020
tonmo
11 min read
Views
1,766
I wrote this in 2004 when the community was actively engaging in cephalopod creative writing. I could never decipher the lyrics to Led Zeppelin's Walter's Walk, and so I used that title as a starting place to create a ceph story around it. --Tony Morelli CHAPTER ONE McEagen knew it wouldn't be...
Original publish date
Apr 8, 2004
Clem
5 min read
Views
2,852
Visit Skot Olsen's site here 1: Captain Obed Architeuthis In 1998, artist Skot Olsen painted "Captain Obed Architeuthis," and introduced a figure into his work that has now become a recurrent, nearly obsessional motif. Captain Obed bobs in a row-boat, his head pinched between a rising sea...
Original publish date
Nov 17, 2003
tonmo
5 min read
Views
3,489
What follows is TONMO.com's exclusive interview conducted 2/3/02 with famed marine author and artist Richard Ellis (read full bio). Richard spoke a bit about recent events and his current work. TONMO.com: You are known as both an artist and a leading historian of the ocean. What came first for...
Contributing Authors
Richard Ellis, interviewed by Tony Morelli
Original publish date
Feb 3, 2002
tonmo
3 min read
Views
1,647
RICHARD ELLIS is currently recognized as the foremost painter of marine natural history subjects in America. His paintings of whales have appeared in Audubon, National Wildlife, Australian Geographic, the Encyclopedia Britannica, and numerous other national and international publications. His...
Contributing Authors
supplied by press / biographer
Original publish date
Aug 20, 2002

Comments

There are no comments to display.

Article information

Author
tonmo
Article read time
4 min read
Views
1,321
Last update

More from tonmo

Top